This or something similar sounds great. (Destiny)

by Durandal, Saturday, October 11, 2014, 05:18 (3940 days ago) @ Postmortem

Having had my loot stolen repeatedly in Boarderlands I have to say Bungie's approach is better, even when 20 Queen's guard bounties dropped helmets for me while my friends got the sniper rifle and ship.

The issue here is that the reward isn't consistent. Sometimes you get things you can't use, or are worse then what you have, or are weapons you don't like, and other times you get that exotic helmet you needed. Any trading is going to be people giving away stuff they don't want for stuff they do.

If anything, there should be a reroll option for loot. Give people an option to turn something they can't use into something different? Say if you got a legendary pulse rifle drop and you already have one maxed out. Hit the reroll and get a pistol instead?