Your initial post doesn’t mention release date requirements. (Gaming)
by Harmanimus 
, Monday, September 09, 2019, 16:45 (1993 days ago) @ cheapLEY
There is no stipulation that a game has to be released in that decade to be the “game of the decade.” He even questions marking criteria. If you go with his “most influential” option it is entirely probable that the game would have come out prior to the decade. 2009 had a lot going on that wasn’t particularly meaningful for the 00’s, just as most things from this year will probably ring louder for their impact on the 20’s. Honestly, any inclusion in a list here with Dark Souls as a progenitor would be better served by Demon’s Souls which came out in ‘09.
Maybe it is splitting hairs. But I stand by the argument for sake of clarity.
Complete thread:
- Game of the Decade -
Cody Miller,
2019-09-08, 20:03
![[*]](themes/default/images/complete_thread.png "Open whole thread")
- Game of the Decade -
cheapLEY,
2019-09-08, 20:25
- Game of the Decade -
Cody Miller,
2019-09-09, 10:32
- Game of the Decade - Harmanimus, 2019-09-09, 13:17
- Game of the Decade - stabbim, 2019-09-10, 12:21
- Game of the Decade -
Cody Miller,
2019-09-09, 10:32
- Game of the Decade -
Ragashingo,
2019-09-08, 21:48
- Interesting that nobody has mentioned Titanfall 2 yet...
![[ [ No text ] ]](themes/default/images/no_text.png "Empty posting / no text")
-
Malagate,
2019-09-09, 06:33
- That’s only because I haven’t responded yet ;) - CruelLEGACEY, 2019-09-09, 08:02
- Game of the Decade -
Cody Miller,
2019-09-09, 10:44
- You're such a classy guy Cody -
Xenos,
2019-09-09, 12:31
- You're such a classy guy Cody -
Cody Miller,
2019-09-09, 12:33
- You're such a classy guy Cody - cheapLEY, 2019-09-09, 13:52
- It's the pretentious nature of your delivery. -
INSANEdrive,
2019-09-09, 15:50
- It's the pretentious nature of your delivery. -
Cody Miller,
2019-09-09, 16:14
- Well. That's my BINGO card folks. Can we ban him now? :P -
INSANEdrive,
2019-09-09, 16:36
- Well. That's my BINGO card folks. Can we ban him now? :P -
Cody Miller,
2019-09-09, 16:40
- Well. That's my BINGO card folks. Can we ban him now? :P - cheapLEY, 2019-09-09, 16:49
- Well. That's my BINGO card folks. Can we ban him now? :P - Kermit, 2019-09-10, 07:35
- C: "...did I do it right?" I: "Were it so easy". - INSANEdrive, 2019-09-10, 10:30
- Well. That's my BINGO card folks. Can we ban him now? :P -
Cody Miller,
2019-09-09, 16:40
- Well. That's my BINGO card folks. Can we ban him now? :P
- It's the pretentious nature of your delivery. -
Cody Miller,
2019-09-09, 16:14
- Ear to ear folks! -
ManKitten,
2019-09-09, 19:44
- Whoa whoa whoa! Who said they were surprised? ;) -
Xenos,
2019-09-10, 13:30
- Whoa whoa whoa! Who said they were surprised? ;)
- You're such a classy guy Cody -
Cody Miller,
2019-09-09, 12:33
- You're such a classy guy Cody -
Xenos,
2019-09-09, 12:31
- Game of the Decade -
Avateur,
2019-09-12, 21:13
- Game of the Decade -
Ragashingo,
2019-09-12, 22:56
- Game of the Decade - Avateur, 2019-09-12, 23:08
- Game of the Decade -
Ragashingo,
2019-09-12, 22:56
- Interesting that nobody has mentioned Titanfall 2 yet...
- Game of the Decade -
Blackt1g3r,
2019-09-09, 07:51
- Game of the Decade - Cody Miller, 2019-09-09, 20:55
- Game of the Decade - Kermit, 2019-09-09, 09:22
- Without spending much time researching... -
kidtsunami,
2019-09-09, 09:35
- I wish spelunky had online multiplayer -
Blackt1g3r,
2019-09-09, 10:29
- Without spending much time researching... - Blackt1g3r, 2019-09-09, 12:03
- I wish spelunky had online multiplayer
- Persona 5 or Nier: Automata. -
EffortlessFury,
2019-09-09, 11:16
- Persona 5 or Nier: Automata. - Korny, 2019-09-09, 11:26
- The Official Game(s) of the Decade -
INSANEdrive,
2019-09-09, 11:25
- You missed the first Super Mario Galaxy! -
marmot 1333,
2019-09-09, 12:37
- 2007. Disqualified. -
INSANEdrive,
2019-09-09, 13:03
- 2007. Disqualified.
- You missed the first Super Mario Galaxy!
- Borderlands 2 -
Schedonnardus,
2019-09-09, 12:47
- Game of the Decade -
breitzen,
2019-09-09, 12:54
- Minecraft was last decade. Came out May 2009. -
Cody Miller,
2019-09-09, 13:02
- You're right! Although a few places I've seen say 2011? - breitzen, 2019-09-09, 13:23
- Your initial post doesn’t mention release date requirements. -
Harmanimus,
2019-09-09, 13:24
- Your initial post doesn’t mention release date requirements. -
cheapLEY,
2019-09-09, 13:50
- Your initial post doesn’t mention release date requirements. -
Harmanimus,
2019-09-09, 16:45
- Your initial post doesn’t mention release date requirements. -
cheapLEY,
2019-09-09, 16:54
- Your initial post doesn’t mention release date requirements. - Harmanimus, 2019-09-09, 17:01
- Your initial post doesn’t mention release date requirements. -
cheapLEY,
2019-09-09, 16:54
- Your initial post doesn’t mention release date requirements. -
Harmanimus,
2019-09-09, 16:45
- "The Decade" isn't exactly a vague timeframe... -
Korny,
2019-09-09, 14:16
- Your initial post doesn’t mention release date requirements. -
cheapLEY,
2019-09-09, 13:50
- According to wikipedia... -
breitzen,
2019-09-09, 13:27
- According to wikipedia... -
Cody Miller,
2019-09-09, 13:51
- According to wikipedia... -
cheapLEY,
2019-09-09, 13:52
- According to wikipedia... - Cody Miller, 2019-09-09, 16:15
- According to wikipedia... -
cheapLEY,
2019-09-09, 13:52
- According to wikipedia... -
Cody Miller,
2019-09-09, 13:51
- Minecraft was last decade. Came out May 2009.
- Game of the Decade -
CruelLEGACEY,
2019-09-09, 17:53
- Game of the Decade -
Cody Miller,
2019-09-09, 18:37
- Game of the Decade -
cheapLEY,
2019-09-09, 19:06
- Game of the Decade - Cody Miller, 2019-09-09, 21:25
- Game of the Decade -
cheapLEY,
2019-09-09, 19:06
- Game of the Decade -
Ragashingo,
2019-09-09, 18:47
- Game of the Decade -
CruelLEGACEY,
2019-09-09, 20:21
- Game of the Decade -
cheapLEY,
2019-09-09, 20:31
- Game of the Decade - CruelLEGACEY, 2019-09-09, 22:37
- Game of the Decade -
cheapLEY,
2019-09-09, 20:31
- Game of the Decade -
CruelLEGACEY,
2019-09-09, 20:21
- Game of the Decade -
Cody Miller,
2019-09-09, 18:37
- I didn't even think of Halo Reach -
Blackt1g3r,
2019-09-10, 07:49
- I didn't even think of Halo Reach -
Cody Miller,
2019-09-10, 08:11
- I didn't even think of Halo Reach - Blackt1g3r, 2019-09-10, 08:23
- Maybe you'll finally realize it's canon. - Kermit, 2019-09-10, 09:38
- I played ODST recently - MacAddictXIV, 2019-09-10, 09:45
- I didn't even think of Halo Reach -
Cody Miller,
2019-09-10, 08:11
- Nier Automata -
narcogen,
2019-09-10, 09:41
- Nier Automata - Cody Miller, 2019-09-10, 21:22
- Consensus -
Cody Miller,
2019-09-10, 10:12
- Consensus -
EffortlessFury,
2019-09-10, 11:39
- Consensus -
Cody Miller,
2019-09-10, 12:15
- Consensus - stabbim, 2019-09-10, 12:26
- Consensus -
Harmanimus,
2019-09-10, 13:03
- Consensus -
Kermit,
2019-09-10, 13:58
- Consensus - Cody Miller, 2019-09-10, 14:17
- Consensus -
Harmanimus,
2019-09-10, 14:43
- Consensus -
CruelLEGACEY,
2019-09-11, 07:21
- +1, and something Bungie could really learn from. -
Malagate,
2019-09-11, 12:23
- +1, and something Bungie could really learn from. -
Cody Miller,
2019-09-11, 12:38
- Feed this to the Writing Team, Clockwork Orange-style. -
Malagate,
2019-09-11, 12:56
- Feed this to the Writing Team, Clockwork Orange-style. - Cody Miller, 2019-09-11, 13:02
- Feed this to the Writing Team, Clockwork Orange-style.
- +1, and something Bungie could really learn from. -
Cody Miller,
2019-09-11, 12:38
- Consensus - EffortlessFury, 2019-09-11, 13:41
- Consensus - Kermit, 2019-09-12, 08:10
- +1, and something Bungie could really learn from. -
Malagate,
2019-09-11, 12:23
- Consensus -
CruelLEGACEY,
2019-09-11, 07:21
- Consensus -
Kermit,
2019-09-10, 13:58
- Consensus -
Cody Miller,
2019-09-10, 12:15
- Consensus -
EffortlessFury,
2019-09-10, 11:39
- INSANEdrives Game of the Decade -
INSANEdrive,
2019-09-10, 12:15
- INSANEdrives Game of the Decade -
Cody Miller,
2019-09-10, 12:24
- INSANEdrives Game of the Decade - INSANEdrive, 2019-09-10, 13:08
- INSANEdrives Game of the Decade -
Cody Miller,
2019-09-10, 12:24
- Whichever Ones Had The Word 'Sonic' In Them. -
Morpheus,
2019-09-10, 14:48
- Although.... - Morpheus, 2019-09-10, 14:50
- Speaking Seriously Now... -
Morpheus,
2019-09-12, 15:08
- Speaking Seriously Now... -
Cody Miller,
2019-09-12, 20:46
- Speaking Seriously Now... -
cheapLEY,
2019-09-12, 20:50
- Speaking Seriously Now... - Avateur, 2019-09-12, 21:07
- Speaking Seriously Now... - Ragashingo, 2019-09-12, 23:04
- Basically This. - Morpheus, 2019-09-13, 18:52
- Speaking Seriously Now... -
cheapLEY,
2019-09-12, 20:50
- Speaking Seriously Now... -
Cody Miller,
2019-09-12, 20:46
- Game of the Decade - Avateur, 2019-09-12, 21:04
- Halo 2 easily. -
Joe Duplessie (SNIPE 316),
2019-09-12, 21:20
- 2004 was not this decade. By any measure. -
Claude Errera,
2019-09-12, 22:41
- 2004 was not this decade. By any measure.
- And the Game of the Decade is… -
Cody Miller,
2019-09-15, 14:34
- A.K.A "Digital Legos" -
INSANEdrive,
2019-09-15, 15:07
- No, that’s LDD, LEGO Digital Designer :| -
Harmanimus,
2019-09-15, 18:01
- AutoCAD is better -
Cody Miller,
2019-09-15, 18:59
- AutoCAD is better
- No, that’s LDD, LEGO Digital Designer :|
- A.K.A "Digital Legos"
- Game of the Decade -
cheapLEY,
2019-09-08, 20:25