To each their own, I suppose.

Adjusting the mix of chat vs game makes sense to me. The one feature I WOULD like, but apparently is not going to be included, is to mix the chat/game audio in my headphones as I often have trouble understanding what my teammates are saying over the game audio. Yet another reason for me to continue using party chat instead of in-game chat.

Uh, don't most headphones that can play system audio in addition to chat already have their own mix controls?

That's a serious question. I invested in surround sound and don't have anyone living with me who cares about volume, so I've never owned or used that type of headphones. It seems odd to me that they wouldn't have their own mix controls, though.

Adjusting the mix of chat vs game makes sense to me. The one feature I WOULD like, but apparently is not going to be included, is to mix the chat/game audio in my headphones as I often have trouble understanding what my teammates are saying over the game audio. Yet another reason for me to continue using party chat instead of in-game chat.

I would think that you could, actually, from the options described. I reckon the wording is just difficult to get across since the standard 'headset' in use for game consoles is those crappy mono-aural bands with the boom mic - not a proper stereo headset.

I'd be more excited if they split the "Game Volume" option into separate options for voice over, sound effects, and music. It'd be adios, Dinklebot; Hello, sweet Destiny soundtrack.

-Disciple

Exactly. This is all they would need to do. The mute music option would be superfluous with proper sliders. With a film, a fixed mix is okay because you are only ever seeing and doing one thing. With a game, not only do you control what you do and see, but you may want to do and see things that fall outside of the range of intended or normal behavior of someone just playing through the story.

-Disciple

Destiny's music is okay, but even I have grown sick of certain tracks after all my playtime. It's no Halo 3, and even in that you could enable custom soundtracks.

What the hell.

Was anyone even asking for this music mute feature? I've never even heard that complaint! Not even Cody was bitching about it.

I'm a little sad to see the new 'mute the soundtrack' feature, I know I won't be using it. I guess if you must listen to your tunes instead of the moving soundtrack now you can. It seems silly to me. I would think it would lessen the enjoyment & emotional connection to the game. II wonder what's next, muting the soundtrack on movies so you can listen to your own music while watching the movie? I think the movie would suffer immensely. Seems silly to me, but to each his own.

EDIT: I'd probably be okay with muting the music for crucible, but I think it's detrimental for PvE.

Well, you can reenact this masterpiece now:

You sir, know exactly how to make me eat my words. I have a major weakness for the Led Zeppelonium, the heavy element of all rock.

But after the reenactment I will be turning the game soundtrack back on. For reals.

I definitely agree with your argument though. The only time I feel it's ever appropriate to play your own music over a game's soundtrack is when you're playing Dead Rising. And even then, it's to reenact Shaun of the Dead by killin' zombies to Queen's Don't Stop Me Now.

And frankly, choosing appropriate mall music is a game mechanic there.

I'm a little sad to see the new 'mute the soundtrack' feature, I know I won't be using it. I guess if you must listen to your tunes instead of the moving soundtrack now you can. It seems silly to me. I would think it would lessen the enjoyment & emotional connection to the game. II wonder what's next, muting the soundtrack on movies so you can listen to your own music while watching the movie? I think the movie would suffer immensely. Seems silly to me, but to each his own.

EDIT: I'd probably be okay with muting the music for crucible, but I think it's detrimental for PvE.

Well, you can reenact this masterpiece now:

You sir, know exactly how to make me eat my words. I have a major weakness for the Led Zeppelonium, the heavy element of all rock.

But after the reenactment I will be turning the game soundtrack back on. For reals.

I'm a little sad to see the new 'mute the soundtrack' feature, I know I won't be using it. I guess if you must listen to your tunes instead of the moving soundtrack now you can. It seems silly to me. I would think it would lessen the enjoyment & emotional connection to the game. II wonder what's next, muting the soundtrack on movies so you can listen to your own music while watching the movie? I think the movie would suffer immensely. Seems silly to me, but to each his own.

Adjusting the mix of chat vs game makes sense to me. The one feature I WOULD like, but apparently is not going to be included, is to mix the chat/game audio in my headphones as I often have trouble understanding what my teammates are saying over the game audio. Yet another reason for me to continue using party chat instead of in-game chat.

EDIT: I'd probably be okay with muting the music for crucible, but I think it's detrimental for PvE.

Well, you can reenact this masterpiece now:

Adjusting the mix of chat vs game makes sense to me. The one feature I WOULD like, but apparently is not going to be included, is to mix the chat/game audio in my headphones as I often have trouble understanding what my teammates are saying over the game audio. Yet another reason for me to continue using party chat instead of in-game chat.

EDIT: I'd probably be okay with muting the music for crucible, but I think it's detrimental for PvE.

Marty's influence is definitely gone from Bungie. RIP.

I hesitate to say that I've evolved on the issue of sliders, and things still aren't the way Cody would like, but a big part of my support of the status quo had to do with Bungie's success in creating an atmosphere, telling a story, and immersing the player in both, and all of that together being the experience of playing the game. Sadly, to me it's clear that Destiny's story, at least for this go-round, isn't as compelling or as immersive as their stories in past games have been, and my old argument against sliders doesn't hold up as well.