I actually helped the development team on that test and do feedback. It was a solid game for only having 2ish developers. Simply put, it failed because apart from the Total War games, the Real Time Tactics genre is basically a dead genre these days.

I think that's because RTT has morphed into Dota, which is simply more complex a genre.

The developers tried to keep everything that was awesome about Myth but spruce it up with more modern mechanics. Double edged sword that was, the hard core Myth community wanted Myth and nothing else so they shit on the game and everyone else didn't know what Myth was and was confused.

I did try to mention it before :D
https://destiny.bungie.org/forum/index.php?id=61829

What's confusing about Magma?

This was a while ago, but getting Myth 1 to run was so hard I gave up.

You can go crazy here

As great as Marathon and Oni could be, I’ll go with Myth. The narration was an effective story telling device at the time and great for atmosphere, but technology would open up some doors to get a touch more direct story telling in the game. I know this is a contentious issue in a more recent Bungie game right now...

But over and above that I like to think about elements of Myth that would be striking now. While a real-time tactical game wouldn’t translate to VR, seeing Thrall inevitably stumbling closer, Soulless float and hurl spears, the earth pounding and scale as a Trow stomps through the mist. It would be full on (maybe too much).

Myth oozed atmosphere, and that could be great in a remake.

I wish project Magma weren’t so confusing. Maybe I’ll install an OS 9 emulator and do it that way. But can you do QuickDraw RAVE that way or would you have to play Myth as software only rendering?

What's confusing about Magma?

Running Myth on modern OSes is really dead simple-- there's no need to mess around with emulators.

I think the thing that stops me from wanting a Myth remake is that to me, at least, it stands up as it is in a way that I am not entirely sure Marathon does, compared to other, linear, story-driven FPS games that are more recent.

Although in a pinch I'd take Marathon 1 and Pathways Into Darkness. It's arguable that Marathon 2 stands up the way it is, and Infinity is a separate thing.

You can go crazy here

As great as Marathon and Oni could be, I’ll go with Myth. The narration was an effective story telling device at the time and great for atmosphere, but technology would open up some doors to get a touch more direct story telling in the game. I know this is a contentious issue in a more recent Bungie game right now...

But over and above that I like to think about elements of Myth that would be striking now. While a real-time tactical game wouldn’t translate to VR, seeing Thrall inevitably stumbling closer, Soulless float and hurl spears, the earth pounding and scale as a Trow stomps through the mist. It would be full on (maybe too much).

Myth oozed atmosphere, and that could be great in a remake.

I wish project Magma weren’t so confusing. Maybe I’ll install an OS 9 emulator and do it that way. But can you do QuickDraw RAVE that way or would you have to play Myth as software only rendering?

Operation Desert Storm.

Remake it as a cross between Call of Duty and Crysis focused on vehicular combat.

I guess my answer would be Desert Storm and Destiny 1 (as an RPG).

You can go crazy here

As great as Marathon and Oni could be, I’ll go with Myth. The narration was an effective story telling device at the time and great for atmosphere, but technology would open up some doors to get a touch more direct story telling in the game. I know this is a contentious issue in a more recent Bungie game right now...

But over and above that I like to think about elements of Myth that would be striking now. While a real-time tactical game wouldn’t translate to VR, seeing Thrall inevitably stumbling closer, Soulless float and hurl spears, the earth pounding and scale as a Trow stomps through the mist. It would be full on (maybe too much).

Myth oozed atmosphere, and that could be great in a remake.

Which reminds me, where the heck is the Marathon Hypearchive Northwest now hosted?

Still part of bungie.org.

http://archives.bungie.org/

I wanted to reply with a thumbs up emoji, but there's no emoji support on the forum.

Which reminds me, where the heck is the Marathon Hypearchive Northwest now hosted?

Still part of bungie.org.

http://archives.bungie.org/

The OSS community has put in a tone of work making marathon run well on modern computers and have added lots of additional features and improvements along the way.

I’d love to play their early stuff, but it all feels and looks like shit now, so it’s not worth it.

I was surprised how replayable the Marathon series was. Yes, the movement was pretty janky, but it still play surprisingly well.

Be sure to check out some amazing fan maps and games. My personal favs were always Marathon Evil and Tempus Irae.

Which reminds me, where the heck is the Marathon Hypearchive Northwest now hosted?

I think I've actually played both of those... I went through some of the fan made stuff. I know I recognize both of those names at least!

I’d love to play their early stuff, but it all feels and looks like shit now, so it’s not worth it.

I was surprised how replayable the Marathon series was. Yes, the movement was pretty janky, but it still play surprisingly well.

Be sure to check out some amazing fan maps and games. My personal favs were always Marathon Evil and Tempus Irae.

Which reminds me, where the heck is the Marathon Hypearchive Northwest now hosted?

I’d love to play their early stuff, but it all feels and looks like shit now, so it’s not worth it.

I was surprised how replayable the Marathon series was. Yes, the movement was pretty janky, but it still play surprisingly well.

You can snap your fingers and get two modern remakes of any Bungie developed or published game. Which two, why, and what would you hope for? You can go crazy here: you can even change genre for the remake if you like.

Marathon 1 & 2.

The Halo series I think holds up as they are (either as the originals in compatibility mode, or in their MCC/Anniversary incarnations. No need to touch them right now, if ever.

The Myth series, I feel, also holds up as they are. If players are unaware or uninterested in Myth, I think that's because of things that are inherent to Myth and the particulars of its gameplay (realtime tactics, no resource management). I don't feel, for instance, that Myth would really benefit if you, say, ported it to the same engine that runs, for example, Halo Wars.

The Marathon games are first person shooters, but running on an engine that has significant limitations and differences from what came later. I think a remake of those scenarios in modern engines (rather than just Halo and Destiny which are similar works with similar themes and broadly similar gameplay) would be something of value.

I'd buy that. I would play that.

Maybe they could add the wave motion cannon.